Gifts or Sacrifices, Limits or Boundaries: A Comparative Analysis of Orthodox and Catholic Approaches to Transplantation

Abstract

The problems of human life and death have always been at the center of Christian culture's attention. Transplantology is a branch of modern medicine that ensures the preservation of life by changing attitudes towards death. Human death is associated with practical moral and medical problems of transferring organs, tissues, and cell cultures from person to person, dead or alive, as well as animal or artificially created organs. The introduction of new medical technologies makes it necessary to address issues about the ethical meaning of death, the moral status of a deceased person, the right of doctors to remove organs of the deceased and the human right to his body after death, and the possibility of religious justification for donation. The article analyzes the solution of these problems in the system of Christian ethical consciousness. The method of achieving this goal is a comparative analysis of official documents of the Russian Orthodox Church and the Catholic Church. The research is carried out in a certain sequence: general attitude to transplantation, theological justification of the work of a transplant doctor, explanation of the principle of solidarity, attitude to types of transplantation, attitude to the dead body, assessment of criteria for human death, abuse and trade of human organs and tissues, donor use of human embryo and fetus tissues in regenerative medicine. In conclusion, differences and common positions in understanding the boundaries that should not be violated in matters of human life and death are identified in the “Fundamentals of the Social Concept of the Russian Orthodox Church” (2000) and in two Catholic documents — the “Charter of Health Workers” (1994) and the “New Charter of Health Workers”(2018).